Student Accountability Resolution Matrix

Updated: July 25, 2025

Introduction

The Policy, Accountability, and Critical Events (PACE) unit serves to advance the University’s mission to develop responsible citizen leaders by supporting the student-run Honor and Judiciary Committees in their ownership and management of student conduct adjudication. For matters that are initially referred to the Accountability Branch of PACE, our staff will always seek to respond in ways that are fair, transparent, and educational. PACE often addresses less serious incidents informally and educationally while referring any situation requiring formal adjudication to the Honor and/or Judiciary Committees. PACE does not adjudicate student conduct cases.

The following Resolution Matrix presents guidelines for addressing referrals that involve student misconduct. This matrix includes case types under the PACE classification system and the unit(s) who may be responsible for resolving the issue in question. Resolution types, potential actions, and potential referrals are referenced, and explanations for these can be found below under Resolution Matrix Terms. PACE staff will generally follow these guidelines unless a case involves aggravating or mitigating factors—in these instances it may be appropriate for University officials to exercise professional judgment in modifying the response accordingly. Please see the Student Accountability Process and Group Accountability Process on the PACE website for more information. Please note that this matrix informs case management practices for matters that are referred to PACE. Any member of the community may also make direct referrals to the University Judiciary Committee and Honor Committee.

Resolution Matrix

Case TypeUnit

First Occurrence

Second+ Occurrence

ResolutionPotential ActionsPotential ReferralsResolutionPotential ActionsPotential Referrals

Alcohol

Driving Under Influence (DUI)PACEFormalMeeting;
Parent Notification
Judiciary CommitteeFormalMeeting;
Parent Notification
Judiciary Committee
Public Intoxication (DIP)PACEInformalMeeting;
Parent Notification (if arrested)
BASICS or WahooWellFormalMeeting;
Parent Notification
Judiciary Committee
Consumption/Possession <21HRLInformalMeeting;
Parent Notification (if arrested)
BASICS or WahooWellInformal or FormalMeeting;
Parent Notification (if arrested)
Judiciary Committee (as appropriate)
PACE
TransportHRLInformalMeetingBASICS or WahooWell; CASS or Residence Life CoordinatorInformal or FormalMeeting and potential parent notificationWahooWell or Judiciary Committee (as appropriate)
PACE
DistributionPACEInformalMeeting;
Parent Notification (if arrested)
BASICS or WahooWell; CASS or Residence Life CoordinatorFormalMeeting;
Parent notification (if arrested)
Judiciary Committee

Damage or Misuse of Property

University PropertyHRLInformalMeeting
Restitution
NoneFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE
Non-University PropertyPACEInformalMeeting
Restitution
NoneFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee

Disorderly or Disruptive Behavior

Disorderly or Disruptive BehaviorHRLInformal or FormalMeetingWahooWell;
Judiciary Committee (if appropriate);
Threat Assessment Team (if appropriate)
FormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
PACE
Disruption of SpeechPACEInformal or FormalMeetingJudiciary Committee (if appropriate);
Threat Assessment Team (if appropriate)
FormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee

Drugs

Consumption/Possession (cannabis vs non-cannabis)HRLInformalMeeting;
Parent Notification (if arrested)
WahooWell;
Care and Support Services or Residence Life Coordinator
FormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE
DistributionPACEFormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate);
Parent Notification (if arrested)
Judiciary CommitteeFormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate)
Judiciary Committee

Endangering Behavior

Physical AssaultPACEFormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate)
Threat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
FormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate)
Threat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
ThreatsPACEInformal or FormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate)
Threat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
FormalMeeting;
Interim Suspension (if appropriate)
Threat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee

Failure to Comply

Failure to ComplyHRLInformalMeetingNoneFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE

Hazing

HazingPACEFormalInitial Inquiry/Investigation; Hazing Evaluation PanelJudiciary CommitteeFormalInitial Inquiry/Investigation; Hazing Evaluation PanelJudiciary Committee

Honor

LyingPACEFormalMeeting (if non-academic)Honor CommitteeFormalMeeting (if non-academic)Honor Committee
CheatingPACEFormalNone (academic)Honor CommitteeFormalNone (academic)Honor Committee
StealingPACEFormalMeeting (if non-academic)Honor CommitteeFormalMeeting (if non-academic)Honor Committee

Other

OtherHRLTBDConsultationConsultationTBDConsultationConsultation
PACE
Fake IDPACEInformalMeetingWahooWellFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee (if appropriate)

Public Health

Public HealthHRLTBDConsultationConsultationTBDConsultationConsultation
PACE

Retaliation

Retaliation (non-PADHR)PACEFormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
FormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
Theft
TheftHRLInformal or FormalMeeting
Restitution
Honor Committee or Judiciary Committee (if appropriate)FormalMeetingHonor Committee or Judiciary Committee
PACE

Unauthorized Entry/Access

Unauthorized Entry/AccessHRLInformalMeetingNoneFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE

Violation of HRL Policies

Violation of HRL PoliciesHRLInformal or FormalMeetingHRLFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE

Violation of Policy or Law

Policy or LawHRLInformal or FormalMeetingVariesFormalMeetingJudiciary Committee
PACE

Weapons or Incendiary Devices

Weapons or Incendiary DevicesPACEFormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee
FormalMeetingThreat Assessment Team;
Judiciary Committee

*Note that Arrest, Interim Suspension, and Contributory Health Impairment categories may be added to cases where appropriate and always will be associated with other underlying classification(s). In addition, the University may issue an interim suspension in appropriate cases pursuant to the University’s policy on interim suspensions. Incidents involving alleged violations of the University’s Sexual Misconduct Policy or Policy on Addressing Discrimination and Harassment are referred to the Office for Equal Opportunity and Civil Rights.

Resolution Matrix Terms

Resolutions

Informal Resolution

This type of resolution results in educational or restorative actions to promote learning and better, healthier choices. A failure to complete informal resolution actions or referrals signals an unwillingness to act in good faith and may result in formal resolution. Informal resolution is generally appropriate for first time, less serious or lower-level offenses as determined by the professional judgment of staff. Note that informal resolution does not result in a disciplinary record for a student and is not considered reportable in the disciplinary clearance process (e.g., for graduate school applications).

Formal Resolution

This type of resolution results in referral to the Honor or Judiciary Committees. In such situations, PACE staff will typically meet with students and/or conduct initial inquires/investigations. Honor or Judiciary Committee outcomes that involve a finding of responsibility will result in a disciplinary record for a student that may be reportable in a disciplinary clearance/background check process.

Actions

Meeting

A meeting allows students to share information, reflect on and learn from their experiences, review and understand relevant policies, and adjust their behavior through informal or formal resolution outcomes.

Parent Notification

A phone call with a student’s parent/guardian informing them about an incident involving their student and the illegal use of alcohol or other drugs. Parents/guardians are encouraged to speak with their student about such behavior. This only applies if the student (1) is tax-dependent, AND (2) was arrested in connection with the incident -or- has engaged in a pattern of such behavior -or- the incident was severe. See University Policy STAF-005.

Restitution

An informal or formal resolution where a student reimburses another student, an organization, or the University for damage to or theft of property. This will not exceed the actual cost of the property.

Referrals

Health and Wellness

Care and Support Services (CASS)

An office within Student Health and Wellness that, among other responsibilities, offers care and support to students experiencing challenges or crises. For example, CASS can offer general support in cases involving the impacts of substance abuse.

Residence Life Coordinator

A professional staff member on the Housing & Residence Life (HRL) team who, among other responsibilities, offers care and support to students experiencing challenges or crises. For example, Residence Life Coordinators can offer general support in cases involving the impacts of substance abuse.

WahooWell

A non-clinical well-being coaching program within Student Health and Wellness that consists of a confidential well-being survey and two or more confidential, one-on-one follow-up meetings with a WahooWell Specialist.

Committees, Panels, or Teams

Hazing Evaluation Panel

A multi-disciplinary team, coordinated by PACE, that reviews reports of hazing and decides appropriate actions pursuant to the Procedures for Reports of Hazing and Virginia law.

Honor Committee

A self-governing student agency organization with delegated authority from the Board of Visitors to investigate and adjudicate alleged violations of the Honor System.

Judiciary Committee

A self-governing student agency organization with delegated authority from the Board of Visitors to investigate and adjudicate alleged violations of the Standards of Conduct.

Threat Assessment Team

A multi-disciplinary team, chaired by the Director of Threat Assessment, that engages in a dynamic process that attempts to understand a person’s motivation and capability regarding violence, increase protective factors against violence, anticipate and minimize triggering events, and protect and support potential targets. This team is not a disciplinary body; however, referrals are made to appropriate authorities.